Explore our expert insights and analysis in leading energy and climate news stories.
The new initiative founded by Resources for the Future, the Center on Global Energy Policy at Columbia University SIPA, and the Bezos Earth Fund will fund research and...
Get the latest as our experts share their insights on global energy policy.
While Iran's first direct attack using missiles and drones against Israel on April 13 did not incur significant damage to military sites or, more importantly, civilian casualties, it...
Hear in-depth conversations with the world’s top energy and climate leaders from government, business, academia, and civil society.
Cleaner alternatives to the oil and gas that power vital industries are necessary for economy-wide decarbonization. E-fuels, or electrofuels, are touted by some as a carbon neutral solution...
Find out more about our upcoming and past events.
This roundtable is open only to currently enrolled Columbia University students. If you are no longer a student and would like to be removed from this mailing list, please...
Reports by Richard Nephew • March 27, 2015
This issue brief, authored by Richard Nephew, Program Director for Economic Statecraft, Sanctions and Energy Markets at the Center on Global Energy Policy, examines the possible application of new sanctions against Iran if a deal is not achievable between Iran and the P5+1. Nephew concludes that new sanctions would be a far riskier strategy to pursue than a successful negotiation and outlines the best way to design a sanctions regime if, unfortunately, it is needed. The brief reviews the logic of sanctions and how they can be best calibrated to achieve desired effects, drawing on lessons from past sanctions experience. Nephew is a former director for Iran at the U.S. National Security Council and was a member of the U.S. nuclear negotiating team with Iran from August 2013 to December 2014. The views expressed here are his own.
The executive summary is below. You can download and read the full brief here (pdf) as well as engage with all of the Center’s content related to sanctions on our dedicated program webpage.
***
Executive Summary
Sanctions will not solve the Iranian nuclear problem. However, sanctions have—and still may—contribute to a solution if judiciously, strategically, and appropriately applied. In short, the brief finds:
A) The best way to design new sanctions against Iran is to ensure that they meet three basic criteria:
B) Sanctions and sanctions-related steps do exist that generally meet these criteria. They are:
C) US success in implementing sanctions along these lines will depend greatly on partner support, which will be risked if the sanctions path is embarked upon without adequate testing of a realistic and reasonable comprehensive solution via negotiations. Permitting the ongoing process to play out is essential.
D) The Administration and Congress ought to begin contingency planning for new sanctions along these lines now, but without crossing the line into formal drafting of bills or similar steps that would undermine negotiations (aside from steps such as removing restrictions on the export of US crude oil, which could assuage concerns about future market impact). A quiet, internal process ought to be initiated along these lines. The focus ought to be on the substance of sanctions, the efficacy of a common US strategy, and the imperative of stopping Iran from acquiring a nuclear weapon rather than on meaningless displays of tough talk or snapping up headlines.
***
While Iran's first direct attack using missiles and drones against Israel on April 13 did not incur significant damage to military sites or, more importantly, civilian casualties, it...
Russia's isolation from the West following its invasion of Ukraine has given new impetus to the country’s already close cooperation with the Central Asian countries of Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan,...
National oil and gas companies in the Gulf Arab States, aspiring to establish themselves as pioneers in low-carbon energy production, are strategically investing in technologies that can mitigate...
Full report
Reports by Richard Nephew • March 27, 2015